10/07/2008

Old wine in new bottles: Two pieces about 'Science'

The Scientist : What Makes Science 'Science'? [2008-10-01]

By James Williams

Here are some of the data from the 74 graduates that I've surveyed to date:

• 76% equated a fact with 'truth' and 'proven'

• 23% defined a theory as 'unproven ideas' with less than half (47%) recognizing a theory as a well evidenced exposition of a natural phenomenon

• 34% defined a law as a rule not to be broken, and forty-one percent defined it as an idea that science fully supports.

What makes me feel embarrassed is that I found difficult to make the definitions by myself.

The Scientist : Why the Philosophy of Science Matters [2008-10-01]

By Richard Gallagher
You might expect that newly minted science graduatesᅠ-ᅠwho presumably think of themselves as scientists, and who I'd thought of as scientistsᅠ-ᅠwould have a well-developed sense of what science is. So it's pretty shocking to discover that a large proportion of them don't have a clue.
Please pay attention to the comment following the article on the site.

No comments: